Porisma

Worked solution

Combine an algebraic range with an intersecting line

The curve CC has equation y=x2+3x−1x−2y=\dfrac{x^2+3x-1}{x-2}, x∈Rx\in\mathbb R, x≠2x\ne2.

(i) Using an algebraic method, find the range of values that yy can take.

(ii) Sketch CC, stating the equations of the asymptotes, axial intercepts and the coordinates of the turning points, if any.

(iii) State the range of values that mm can take such that the equation x2+3x−1x−2=m(x−2)+7\dfrac{x^2+3x-1}{x-2}=m(x-2)+7 has 2 distinct solutions, justifying your answer.

2018/RI/Promo/9

CJC · Lecture · Example 13

Answer

(i) y≤1y\le1 or y≥13y\ge13. (ii) Asymptotes x=2x=2, y=x+5y=x+5; intercepts (0,1/2)(0,1/2) and ((−3±13)/2,0)((-3\pm\sqrt{13})/2,0); local maximum (−1,1)(-1,1) and local minimum (5,13)(5,13). (iii) m>1m>1.

(i) Apply the discriminant to the quadratic in x

Answer

y≤1y\le1 or y≥13y\ge13.

The Teacher completes the Student blanks with the full chain

y=x2+3x−1x−2,xy−2y=x2+3x−1,x2+(3−y)x+(2y−1)=0.\begin{aligned}y&=\frac{x^2+3x-1}{x-2},\\xy-2y&=x^2+3x-1,\\x^2+(3-y)x+(2y-1)&=0.\end{aligned}

For a real input, the discriminant is nonnegative:

(3−y)2−4(1)(2y−1)≥0,y2+9−6y−8y+4≥0,y2−14y+13=(y−1)(y−13)≥0.\begin{aligned}(3-y)^2-4(1)(2y-1)&\ge0,\\y^2+9-6y-8y+4&\ge0,\\y^2-14y+13=(y-1)(y-13)&\ge0.\end{aligned}

Thus y≤1y\le1 or y≥13y\ge13. Independently, substituting the forbidden input 2 into the recovered quadratic gives 9 for every yy, so a recovered root can never be 2. The discriminant condition is sufficient too; both endpoints are attained at the turning points below.

How did this part go?

(ii) Read and verify the source graph

Both copies give

y=x+5+9x−2,y=x+5+\frac9{x-2},

and label asymptotes x=2x=2, y=x+5y=x+5, turns (−1,1),(5,13)(-1,1),(5,13), yy-intercept 1/21/2, and rounded xx-intercepts −3.30 and 0.303. Independently solving x2+3x−1=0x^2+3x-1=0 gives exact roots (−3±13)/2(-3\pm\sqrt{13})/2; substituting 0 gives y=1/2y=1/2. Derivative 1−9/(x−2)21-9/(x-2)^2 changes +→−+\to- at −1 and −→+-\to+ at 5, verifying the local maximum/minimum and the range endpoints. The numerator at 2 is 9, so the pole is genuine.

Expand diagram

Use the scrollbars or arrow keys to inspect details.

Rational curve with vertical x=2 and slant y=x+5, turns (−1,1),(5,13), intercept (0,1/2), source-rounded zeros −3.30,0.303 and asymptote intersection A(2,7). Added illustrative line with slope 2 crosses both branches.
Rational curve with vertical x=2 and slant y=x+5, turns (−1,1),(5,13), intercept (0,1/2), source-rounded zeros −3.30,0.303 and asymptote intersection A(2,7). Added illustrative line with slope 2 crosses both branches.
Rational curve with vertical x=2 and slant y=x+5, turns (−1,1),(5,13), intercept (0,1/2), source-rounded zeros −3.30,0.303 and asymptote intersection A(2,7). Added illustrative line with slope 2 crosses both branches.
How did this part go?

(iii) Use the line through the asymptote intersection

Answer

m>1m>1.

The source line is l:y=m(x−2)+7l:y=m(x-2)+7, so every member passes through A=(2,7)A=(2,7) with gradient mm. This point is the intersection of CC’s two asymptotes, not a point on CC. To meet both branches in two distinct points, the source says the line must be steeper than y=x+5y=x+5, whose gradient is 1. Its conclusion is m>1m>1; this also ensures a positive gradient. The added blue line in the reconstruction is the illustrative choice m=2m=2, not another printed numerical condition.

How did this part go?

Verify distinct solutions without a screen

Independently put t=x−2≠0t=x-2\ne0. Then CC is y=t+7+9/ty=t+7+9/t and the line is y=mt+7y=mt+7. Equating gives

9t=(m−1)t,(m−1)t2=9.\frac9t=(m-1)t,\qquad(m-1)t^2=9.

If m>1m>1, t=±3/m−1t=\pm3/\sqrt{m-1} gives two distinct nonzero real inputs, one on each side of the pole. If m=1m=1 the equation is impossible; if m<1m<1 its left side is nonpositive. Thus the source condition is necessary and sufficient.

How did this part go?

Common mistakes

A(2,7) is on the asymptotes and every line in the family, but x=2 is excluded from C. A discriminant condition still needs the original domain check.

Solution notes

Printed attribution 2018/RI/Promo/9 retained separately; no marks printed. Teacher completes the discriminant chain. Both copies already print the same curve and geometric line argument. Exact intercepts and algebraic sufficiency checks are independent supplements.

Read the hint