Worked solution
Compare an ordered third success with exactly three successes
A firm sells two types of electrical components, and .
Type components are packed in boxes of 50. On average, 2% of the Type components are faulty.
(i) State, in context, two assumptions needed for the number of faulty components of Type in a box to be well-modelled by a binomial distribution. marks
You are now given that the number of faulty components of type in a box follows a binomial distribution.
(ii) Find the probability that a box of these components contains more than 1 faulty component. marks
Five boxes of Type components are selected at random.
(iii) Find the probability that the fifth box is the third box selected which has more than one faulty component. marks
(iv) Find the probability that there are 3 boxes with more than 1 faulty component each. marks
(v) Explain why the answer to part (iv) is greater than the answer to part (iii). mark
[2021/ASRJC/II/10]
CJC · Review Problems · Question 16
Answer
(ii) ; (iii) ; (iv) ; (v) (iii) is a proper subset of (iv).
(i)
Assume that whether one Type A component is faulty is independent of whether any other is faulty, and that each Type A component has the same fault probability .02.
(ii)
Let . Then , printed as .26423 (5 s.f.) and .264 (3 s.f.). Use the unrounded q in later calculations.
(iii) Method 1: ordered arrangements
The first four boxes must contain exactly two qualifying boxes and the fifth must qualify. With independent box outcomes, the probability is (3 s.f.).
(iii) Method 2: a first-four count
Let count qualifying boxes among the first four. Then the probability is , giving the same .0599. The source uses rounded q=.26423; its final result agrees.
(iv)
For , (3 s.f.).
(v)
The event in (iii) is a subset of the event in (iv): it imposes the additional requirement that the fifth box is the third qualifying one. Other orders also contribute positive probability to (iv), so its probability is greater. The two formulas have ratio 6/10=3/5, confirming the comparison.
Common mistakes
Exactly three qualifying boxes among five does not require the fifth to qualify.
Solution notes
The ordered-event calculation assumes independent box outcomes with the same q.