Worked solution
Relate separated arithmetic terms to a geometric progression
The second, fifth and tenth terms of an arithmetic progression with nonzero common difference are the first three terms of a geometric progression.
(i) Find the common ratio. marks
(ii) The first terms of the AP and GP are and . Find the least n for which the GP’s n-th term exceeds the AP’s n-th term by at least . marks
[2022/CJC/Promo/2]
CJC · Review problems · Question 17
Answer
; least .
(i) Method 1: equate adjacent geometric ratios
Write the AP as , , and the GP as . Then , , . Thus , so . Rejecting gives and .
(i) Method 2: divide the successive differences
and . Since , the first difference is nonzero, so division is valid and .
(i) Method 3: eliminate d and solve the ratio quadratic
Use in . With , . The root would give , so reject it and retain .
(ii) Calibrate and check the integer threshold
From and , . The difference is . It increases for , since .
| n | D_n (approximately) |
|---|---|
| 10 | 868.06 |
| 11 | 1461.4 |
| 12 | 2451.7 |
Thus the least n with is .
Common mistakes
The AP’s nonzero common difference rules out the apparently possible GP ratio 1.