Porisma

Worked solution

Rational curve and ellipse: exactly two intersections

Sketch the graph of y=2x(x−μ)y=\dfrac2{x(x-\mu)}, where μ\mu is a positive constant, indicating clearly any axial intercept(s), asymptote(s) and coordinates of turning point(s).

Given a=μ2a=\dfrac\mu2, deduce the range of values of bb in terms of μ\mu, such that the graphs of b(x−a)2+a2y2=a2bb(x-a)^2+a^2y^2=a^2b and y=2x(x−μ)y=\dfrac2{x(x-\mu)} intersect twice, where aa and bb are positive real numbers.

[2010/NJC/Promo/6]

CJC · Discussion · Question 3

Answer

Asymptotes: x=0x=0, x=μx=\mu, y=0y=0; turning point (μ/2,−8/μ2)(\mu/2,-8/\mu^2); no axial intercepts. Exactly two intersections when b>64/μ4b>64/\mu^4.

Rational sketch

There are no axial intercepts: the numerator never vanishes and x=0x=0 is excluded. Asymptotes are x=0,x=μ,y=0x=0,x=\mu,y=0. Differentiate: y′=−2(2x−μ)(x2−μx)2y^\prime=\dfrac{-2(2x-\mu)}{(x^2-\mu x)^2}. Hence the sole stationary point is (μ/2,−8/μ2)(\mu/2,-8/\mu^2), a maximum on the negative middle branch. The exterior branches are positive. The graph is symmetric about x=μ/2x=\mu/2.

How did this part go?

Ellipse comparison

Divide by a2ba^2b: (x−a)2a2+y2b=1\dfrac{(x-a)^2}{a^2}+\dfrac{y^2}{b}=1. Centre (μ/2,0)(\mu/2,0), horizontal semi-axis a=μ/2a=\mu/2, vertical semi-axis b\sqrt b. The ellipse occupies 0≤x≤μ0\le x\le\mu, and the rational graph is negative there. The lower ellipse must extend below the rational maximum: b>8/μ2\sqrt b>8/\mu^2, hence b>64/μ4b>64/\mu^4. Equality gives one tangent intersection; a smaller bb gives none. To check that the strict condition gives exactly two, write u=x−au=x-a, z=a2−u2>0z=a^2-u^2>0. Equating squared ordinates gives bz/a2=4/z2bz/a^2=4/z^2, or z3=4a2/bz^3=4a^2/b. There is a unique admissible z<a2z<a^2 exactly when b>4/a4=64/μ4b>4/a^4=64/\mu^4, and it yields two symmetric nonzero values of uu.

How did this part go?

Compare your sketch

Expand diagram

Use the scrollbars or arrow keys to inspect details.

Illustration μ=2,a=1,b=9: rational graph with vertical asymptotes 0 and μ and horizontal asymptote y=0, middle maximum (μ/2,−8/μ²), and an ellipse centred at (μ/2,0) with semi-axes μ/2 and √b. Its bottom lies below the middle maximum, producing two intersections. The symbolic condition is b>64/μ⁴.
Illustration μ=2,a=1,b=9: rational graph with vertical asymptotes 0 and μ and horizontal asymptote y=0, middle maximum (μ/2,−8/μ²), and an ellipse centred at (μ/2,0) with semi-axes μ/2 and √b. Its bottom lies below the middle maximum, producing two intersections. The symbolic condition is b>64/μ⁴.
Illustration μ=2,a=1,b=9: rational graph with vertical asymptotes 0 and μ and horizontal asymptote y=0, middle maximum (μ/2,−8/μ²), and an ellipse centred at (μ/2,0) with semi-axes μ/2 and √b. Its bottom lies below the middle maximum, producing two intersections. The symbolic condition is b>64/μ⁴.

Solution notes

The source has separate rational-curve and ellipse sketches; the reconstruction overlays both while retaining all their symbolic labels. Geometry uses the explicitly labelled example μ=2,b=9.