Porisma

Worked solution

Rational curve: coefficients, hyperbola comparison and stationary points

The curve CC has equation y=ax2+bx+cx−1y=\dfrac{ax^2+bx+c}{x-1}, where aa, bb and cc are non-zero constants.

(a) It is given that CC passes through the point (3,23/2)(3,23/2) and has a minimum point at (2,10)(2,10).

(i) Find the values of aa, bb and cc.

(ii) Sketch CC, giving the coordinates of any turning points, points of intersection with the axes and the equations of any asymptotes.

(iii) Find the set of values of m/km/k, where mm and kk are positive constants, such that the curve with equation x2k2−(y−1)2m2=1\dfrac{x^2}{k^2}-\dfrac{(y-1)^2}{m^2}=1 does not intersect CC.

(b) In the case when a=−1a=-1 and b=−1b=-1, find the set of values of cc, where c≠2c\ne2, such that CC has no stationary point.

[2013/VJC/II/2]

CJC · Discussion · Question 4

Answer

(a)(i) a=3,b=−2,c=2a=3,b=-2,c=2. (ii) Maximum (0,−2)(0,-2), minimum (2,10)(2,10); yy-intercept (0,−2)(0,-2); no xx-intercepts; asymptotes x=1x=1, y=3x+1y=3x+1. (iii) 0<m/k≤30<m/k\le3. (b) c>2c>2 (the question excludes c=2c=2).

(a)(i)

The points give 9a+3b+c=239a+3b+c=23 and 4a+2b+c=104a+2b+c=10. The derivative is ax2−2ax−b−c(x−1)2\dfrac{ax^2-2ax-b-c}{(x-1)^2}; stationarity at x=2x=2 gives b+c=0b+c=0. Solving these three equations (the source uses a GC) gives a=3,b=−2,c=2a=3,b=-2,c=2. The lecturer guidance in the Conics Teacher copy (PDF 28, printed 140) recommends using a system of linear equations (SOLE) for these three conditions. Set up all three equations before solving for a,b,ca,b,c; reviewing simultaneous equations in advance helps. This makes the source’s GC solution a system-solving step rather than an unexplained coefficient guess.

How did this part go?

(a)(ii)

Long division gives y=3x+1+3x−1y=3x+1+\dfrac3{x-1}. The asymptotes are x=1x=1 and y=3x+1y=3x+1. Since y′=3−3/(x−1)2y^\prime=3-3/(x-1)^2, stationary inputs are x=0,2x=0,2, giving a maximum (0,−2)(0,-2) and minimum (2,10)(2,10). The sole axial intersection is (0,−2)(0,-2): 3x2−2x+2=03x^2-2x+2=0 has negative discriminant 4−24=−204-24=-20, so no real xx-intercepts.

How did this part go?

(a)(iii)

The comparison hyperbola has centre (0,1)(0,1) and asymptotes y=1±(m/k)xy=1\pm(m/k)x. Comparing the positive-gradient asymptote with y=3x+1y=3x+1 gives the source answer 0<m/k≤30<m/k\le3, including equality. For a check beyond the sketch, put r=m/kr=m/k. At an intersection, y−1=3x+3/(x−1)y-1=3x+3/(x-1) and r2=(y−1)2/(x2−k2)r^2=(y-1)^2/(x^2-k^2). If x<0x<0 or x>1x>1, ∣y−1∣>3∣x∣|y-1|>3|x|. For 0<x<10<x<1, ∣y−1∣−3x=3/(1−x)−6x>0|y-1|-3x=3/(1-x)-6x>0 because 1−2x+2x2>01-2x+2x^2>0. Thus every intersection requires r>3r>3. Conversely for any fixed k>0k>0, on x>max⁡(k,1)x>\max(k,1) this ratio is continuous, tends to infinity at the left boundary and to 33 as x→∞x\to\infty, so every r>3r>3 produces an intersection. Therefore 0<r≤30<r\le3 is exact.

How did this part go?

(b)

With a=b=−1a=b=-1, y′=−x2+2x+1−c(x−1)2y^\prime=\dfrac{-x^2+2x+1-c}{(x-1)^2}. For no stationary input, the numerator quadratic must have negative discriminant: 22−4(−1)(1−c)=8−4c<02^2-4(-1)(1-c)=8-4c<0, so c>2c>2. For c<2c<2, its two roots 1±2−c1\pm\sqrt{2-c} are in the domain. The source separately notes that at c=2c=2, y=(x−1)(−x−2)x−1=−x−2y=\dfrac{(x-1)(-x-2)}{x-1}=-x-2 for x≠1x\ne1, also with no stationary point, but that case is explicitly excluded in the question.

How did this part go?

Compare your sketch

Expand diagram

Use the scrollbars or arrow keys to inspect details.

Blue rational curve has maximum/y-intercept (0,−2), minimum (2,10), no x-intercepts, asymptotes x=1,y=3x+1. Green comparison hyperbola is centred at (0,1) and shown at k=1,m=3, with asymptotes y=1±3x. Its branches do not cross C at this boundary ratio; all ratios 0<m/k≤3 avoid intersection.
Blue rational curve has maximum/y-intercept (0,−2), minimum (2,10), no x-intercepts, asymptotes x=1,y=3x+1. Green comparison hyperbola is centred at (0,1) and shown at k=1,m=3, with asymptotes y=1±3x. Its branches do not cross C at this boundary ratio; all ratios 0<m/k≤3 avoid intersection.
Blue rational curve has maximum/y-intercept (0,−2), minimum (2,10), no x-intercepts, asymptotes x=1,y=3x+1. Green comparison hyperbola is centred at (0,1) and shown at k=1,m=3, with asymptotes y=1±3x. Its branches do not cross C at this boundary ratio; all ratios 0<m/k≤3 avoid intersection.

Common mistakes

Equal asymptote gradients do not imply the curves intersect. Here the boundary ratio m/k=3 is included.

Solution notes

The source’s “stationary points of c” in (b) means stationary points of C. Its original wording/extraction is retained. The comparison graph explicitly uses k=1,m=3; the proof covers all positive k,m.

Teacher guidance additionally compared against Conics Lecture Teacher PDF 28 / printed 140 and integrated into (a)(i); review retained in evidence/review-cjc-conics-lecture.md.