Porisma

Worked solution

Fit crane profits and assess a sales target

An engineering company makes cranes. The numbers sold xx in each three-month period for two years and the profits yy (thousand dollars) on those sales are:

xxyy
15290
17350
13270
21430
16340
22410
14300
18360

(i) Sketch the scatter diagram as shown on your calculator.

(ii) Find xˉ\bar x and yˉ\bar y and mark their point on the scatter diagram.

(iii) Calculate the regression of yy on xx and draw it on the scatter diagram.

(iv) Calculate the product moment correlation coefficient and comment on it in relation to the scatter.

(v) Estimate the profit corresponding to a target of 20 cranes for the next three-month period.

(vi) Comment on the validity of using the regression from (iii) to predict profit if 40 cranes were sold in a three-month period.

[2008/H1/I/11]

CJC · Discussion · Question 3

(i) Keep the profit units and paired order

Answer

The eight observations show a strong rising, approximately linear pattern.

Plot cranes sold horizontally and profit in thousand dollars vertically. Preserve all eight three-month observations. The reconstructed diagram includes the mean point and fitted line requested in the following parts; its input axis is cropped to 13–22 and its profit axis starts at zero.

How did this part go?

(ii) Mark the mean point

Answer

(xˉ,yˉ)=(17,343.75)(\bar x,\bar y)=(17,343.75).

The sums are ∑x=136\sum x=136 and ∑y=2750\sum y=2750 across eight periods. Thus xˉ=136/8=17\bar x=136/8=17 and yˉ=2750/8=343.75\bar y=2750/8=343.75. Both printed values are retained. The mean point is circled on the scatter and lies on the fitted line.

How did this part go?

(iii) Calculate and draw the regression

Answer

y=17.1x+53.3y=17.1x+53.3 (3 s.f.).

The independently calculated centred sums are Sxx=72S_{xx}=72 and Sxy=1230S_{xy}=1230, giving

b=123072=20512,a=343.75−17b=1603.b=\frac{1230}{72}=\frac{205}{12},\qquad a=343.75-17b=\frac{160}{3}.

Hence y=(205/12)x+160/3y=(205/12)x+160/3, reported as the printed y=17.1x+53.3y=17.1x+53.3. The diagram uses the full-precision line rather than rounded coefficients.

How did this part go?

(iv) Relate r to the plotted pattern

Answer

r=0.969r=0.969 (3 s.f.), consistent with a strong positive linear pattern.

Using Syy=22387.5S_{yy}=22387.5, calculate r=1230/72(22387.5)=0.9688043135…r=1230/\sqrt{72(22387.5)}=0.9688043135\ldots, matching the printed 0.9690.969. The scatter shows points relatively close to a rising line; neither perfect correlation nor causation is claimed.

How did this part go?

(v) Predict profit at the target

Answer

Predicted profit: $395,000.

Use the full coefficients at x=20x=20:

y=20512(20)+1603=395.\begin{aligned}&y\\ & =\frac{205}{12}(20)+\frac{160}{3}\\ & =395.\end{aligned}

Since yy is measured in thousands of dollars, the predicted profit is $395,000, agreeing with the printed answer. Using the rounded equation would give 395.3 thousand instead; retain precision until the final conversion. The target 20 lies inside the observed 13–22 sales range, though future conditions still need to remain comparable.

How did this part go?

(vi) Check the proposed sales input

Answer

The prediction at 40 cranes is unreliable extrapolation.

The observed quarterly sales range is 13–22 cranes, so 40 is well outside it. The fitted sales–profit relationship may change at that scale, for example if production costs or capacity change. These are possible reasons for caution, not extra data in the source. Strong correlation within the observed sample does not establish validity at 40.

How did this part go?

Compare your sketch

Expand diagram

Use the scrollbars or arrow keys to inspect details.

All eight exact pairs [(15, 290), (17, 350), (13, 270), (21, 430), (16, 340), (22, 410), (14, 300), (18, 360)]. Cranes sold x is horizontal, Profit ($000) vertical. Blue fitted line uses full coefficients 53.3333333333+17.0833333333x. Mean point (17,343.75) circled. Input axis is cropped; response axis starts at zero.
All eight exact pairs [(15, 290), (17, 350), (13, 270), (21, 430), (16, 340), (22, 410), (14, 300), (18, 360)]. Cranes sold x is horizontal, Profit ($000) vertical. Blue fitted line uses full coefficients 53.3333333333+17.0833333333x. Mean point (17,343.75) circled. Input axis is cropped; response axis starts at zero.
All eight exact pairs [(15, 290), (17, 350), (13, 270), (21, 430), (16, 340), (22, 410), (14, 300), (18, 360)]. Cranes sold x is horizontal, Profit ($000) vertical. Blue fitted line uses full coefficients 53.3333333333+17.0833333333x. Mean point (17,343.75) circled. Input axis is cropped; response axis starts at zero.

Solution notes

All eight pairs, six asks and attribution retained. Printed key gives means, regression, correlation and $395000; complete working, scatter/line/mean marker and validity explanations authored and independently checked. No printed marks.