Worked solution
Connect a cross-product relation to areas and a nonzero linear combination
Relative to the origin , three distinct fixed points , and have position vectors , and respectively. It is known that is a unit vector, , and the angle is .
(i) State the geometrical interpretation of . mark
It is further given that .
(ii) Find the ratio of the area of triangle to the area of triangle . marks
(iii) Show that where , .
By considering , find the exact values of . marks
[2016/HCI/Promo/7]
CJC · Discussion · Question 12
Answer
(i) Projection length of c onto b. (ii) Area ratio . (iii) , .
(i) Interpret the absolute scalar product
Because b is a unit vector, is the nonnegative length of the projection of c onto b. The absolute-value bars in the printed question are essential.
(ii) Compare the two triangle areas
The given vector relation implies . Both triangle areas are half the corresponding cross-product magnitude, so their ratio is . The areas are nonzero: if both cross products vanished, a and c would both be parallel to nonzero b, contrary to their 60°angle.
(iii) Establish the linear relationship
Use antisymmetry to rewrite
Since b is nonzero, for real k. This combination cannot be zero: . Thus .
(iii) Square both sides with a dot product
Hence . Both signs are retained because the statement does not fix the orientation of b.
Common mistakes
The prompt’s projection expression has absolute-value bars; it is a length, not a signed scalar component. Squaring gives two possible signs for k.
Solution notes
The page image confirms absolute bars in(i), ℝ and k≠0 in(iii), and printed marks 1,2,6. These are extraction losses, not source errors. An explicit nonzero argument supplements the source’s asserted k≠0.