Porisma

Worked solution

Classify stationary points on two implicit branches

Given the curve 3x2−2y=y23x^2-2y=y^2, determine the coordinates and nature of the stationary points.

CJC · Lecture · Example 2

Differentiate the original relation implicitly

6x−2y′=2yy′6x-2y^{\prime}=2yy^{\prime}, so y′=6x/[2(y+1)]y^{\prime}=6x/[2(y+1)]. Both originals note that there is no need to make yy the subject before differentiating. On this real curve (y+1)2=1+3x2>0(y+1)^2=1+3x^2>0, so y+1≠0y+1\ne0; no real curve point is lost by this division.

How did this part go?

Find both stationary coordinates

y′=0y^{\prime}=0 gives x=0x=0. Substitute into the original relation: y2+2y=0y^2+2y=0, hence y(y+2)=0y(y+2)=0 and y=0y=0 or −2-2. The candidates are (0,0)(0,0) and (0,−2)(0,-2), on two different branches.

How did this part go?

Differentiate the undivided equation again

From 6x−2y′=2yy′6x-2y^{\prime}=2yy^{\prime} obtain 6−2y′′=2yy′′+2(y′)26-2y^{\prime\prime}=2yy^{\prime\prime}+2(y^{\prime})^2. Thus y′′=[6−2(y′)2]/[2(y+1)]y^{\prime\prime}=[6-2(y^{\prime})^2]/[2(y+1)]. The Teacher note explains why this second derivative test is convenient here, unlike Example 1: the implicit first-derivative equation makes the second derivative relatively easy to obtain.

How did this part go?

Classify each branch locally

At both stationary points y′=0y^{\prime}=0. At (0,0)(0,0), y′′=3>0y^{\prime\prime}=3>0, so it is a local minimum. At (0,−2)(0,-2), y′′=−3<0y^{\prime\prime}=-3<0, so it is a local maximum. The source prints the signs and conclusions; these numerical second-derivative values are independently evaluated.

How did this part go?

Retain the Teacher graphing alternative

Complete the square: y2+2y=3x2y^2+2y=3x^2, (y+1)2−1=3x2(y+1)^2-1=3x^2, (y+1)2=1+3x2(y+1)^2=1+3x^2, and y=−1±1+3x2y=-1\pm\sqrt{1+3x^2}. The Teacher blue completion and labelled sketch plot both branches and confirm minimum (0,0)(0,0) on the upper branch and maximum (0,−2)(0,-2) on the lower. The Student graphing space is blank. Plotting both branches does not turn the whole relation into one single-valued function.

How did this part go?

Compare your sketch

Expand diagram

Use the scrollbars or arrow keys to inspect details.

Two branches y=−1+sqrt(1+3x²) and y=−1−sqrt(1+3x²), with upper-branch minimum (0,0) and lower-branch maximum (0,−2), each horizontal at the vertex.
Two branches y=−1+sqrt(1+3x²) and y=−1−sqrt(1+3x²), with upper-branch minimum (0,0) and lower-branch maximum (0,−2), each horizontal at the vertex.
Two branches y=−1+sqrt(1+3x²) and y=−1−sqrt(1+3x²), with upper-branch minimum (0,0) and lower-branch maximum (0,−2), each horizontal at the vertex.

Common mistakes

Keep both branches and both y-coordinates; a second derivative test is applied to a local branch.

Solution notes

Both originals visually compared. Complete source working and distinct Teacher guidance integrated; independently authored domain/precision qualifications are identified. No printed marks or past-paper attribution.

Read the hint