Porisma

Worked solution

Differentiate a factored cubic and distinguish a repeated stationary point

(i) Determine the turning-point coordinates for y=−(x+a)(x+b)2y=-(x+a)(x+b)^2, where a,b are constants.

(ii) Sketch it with axial intercepts and turning points labelled when(a)a>0,b<0; and (b)a<b<0.

CJC · Review problems · Question 1

Answer

For a≠b: (−b,0)(-b,0) and (−(2a+b)/3,4(b−a)3/27)(-(2a+b)/3,4(b-a)^3/27). If a=b: one stationary inflection, no turn. Regime sketches shown.

(i) Differentiate the two factors

y′=−[(x+b)2+2(x+a)(x+b)]=−(x+b)[x+b+2(x+a)]=−(x+b)(3x+2a+b)y'=-[(x+b)^2+2(x+a)(x+b)]=-(x+b)[x+b+2(x+a)]=-(x+b)(3x+2a+b). Thus stationary inputs are x=−bx=-b or x=−(2a+b)/3x=-(2a+b)/3.

How did this part go?

(i) Substitute to obtain both coordinate formulae

At x=−b,y=0. At x=−(2a+b)/3x=-(2a+b)/3, the source substitution gives y=−[−(2a+b)/3+a][−(2a+b)/3+b]2=−[(a−b)/3][(−2a+2b)/3]2=4(b−a)3/27y=-[-(2a+b)/3+a][-(2a+b)/3+b]^2=-[(a-b)/3][(-2a+2b)/3]^2=4(b-a)^3/27. Thus the two coordinates are (−b,0)(-b,0) and (−(2a+b)/3,4(b−a)3/27)(-(2a+b)/3,4(b-a)^3/27).

How did this part go?

(i) Check the coincident-constant case

The source calls both formulae turning points. This is correct for a≠b. If a=b, they coincide and y=−(x+a)3y=-(x+a)^3 has a stationary inflection at (−a,0), with no change of direction; it is not a turning point. Both strict regimes in(ii)have a≠b.

How did this part go?

(ii) Identify the intercepts and ordering

All source intercepts are (0,−ab²),(−a,0),(−b,0). The double zero x=−b touches the axis and is a turn for the stated regimes; x=−a is a crossing.

How did this part go?

(ii)(a) Opposite signs

For a>0,b<0, −a<0<−b and −ab²<0. The second stationary coordinate has negative height and is a local minimum; (−b,0) is a local maximum. The y-intercept is below the axis. The source drawing places the other turn left of the y-axis, but the assumptions do not fix that: −(2a+b)/3-(2a+b)/3 can have either sign. The example panel shows one allowed placement.

How did this part go?

(ii)(b) Both constants negative

For a<b<0, 0<−b<−a and −ab²>0. The source sketch has a minimum at (−b,0) and a maximum at (−(2a+b)/3,4(b−a)3/27)(-(2a+b)/3,4(b-a)^3/27) between the two positive zeros, with a positive y-intercept. Both curves rise to the left and fall to the right.

How did this part go?

Compare your sketch

Expand diagram

Use the scrollbars or arrow keys to inspect details.

Two negative-leading cubic sketches retain all symbolic source intercepts and turning coordinates. The first has a positive a and negative b, the second a<b<0. Explicit example values illustrate the regimes; the working treats the general constants.
Two negative-leading cubic sketches retain all symbolic source intercepts and turning coordinates. The first has a positive a and negative b, the second a<b<0. Explicit example values illustrate the regimes; the working treats the general constants.
Two negative-leading cubic sketches retain all symbolic source intercepts and turning coordinates. The first has a positive a and negative b, the second a<b<0. Explicit example values illustrate the regimes; the working treats the general constants.

Common mistakes

A repeated zero of the derivative need not be a turning point. The source sketch in(a)does not fix every feature’s position relative to the y-axis.

Solution notes

If a=b, the stationary coordinate is an inflection rather than a turn.

The example parameter values illustrate the two regimes; the coordinate formulae apply generally.

Read the hint