Porisma

Worked solution

Use a cosine amplitude bound that works for every phase and frequency

Sketch y=(2x2+1)/(x−1)y=(2x^2+1)/(x-1) with all turning points, axial intercepts and asymptotes. Hence state the values of a for which 2x2+1=a(x−1)cos⁡(bx+c)2x^2+1=a(x-1)\cos(bx+c), x≠1, has no real solution for all b,c. marks

[2010/RI(JC)/Promo/3]

CJC · Review problems · Question 4

Answer

Exact amplitude range 4−26<a<26−44-2\sqrt6<a<2\sqrt6-4; source rounded bounds approximately −0.899<a<0.899.

Divide and find the graph features

y=2x+2+3/(x−1)y=2x+2+3/(x-1), with asymptotes x=1 and y=2 x+2. There is no x-intercept since 2 x²+1>0; the y-intercept is (0,−1). The turns are (1−6/2,4−26)(1-\sqrt6/2,4-2\sqrt6), maximum≈(−0.225,−0.899), and (1+6/2,4+26)(1+\sqrt6/2,4+2\sqrt6), minimum≈(2.22,8.90), retaining the source labels.

How did this part go?

Compare with a bounded cosine

Dividing the equation by x−1 gives (2x2+1)/(x−1)=acos⁡(bx+c)(2x^2+1)/(x-1)=a\cos(bx+c). The source instructs sketching the cosine on the rational graph. For any b,c, its outputs lie in[−|a|,|a|]. The rational curve has outputs y≤4−2√6 or y≥4+2√6. Thus the symmetric cosine band avoids it if ∣a∣<26−4|a|<2\sqrt6-4.

How did this part go?

Keep the exact strict boundary

The exact range is 4−26<a<26−44-2\sqrt6<a<2\sqrt6-4. The source writes −0.899<a<0.899 using the rounded maximum magnitude; these are approximate boundary labels, not exact endpoints. At |a|=2√6−4 one can choose a phase giving the rational curve’s maximum; for larger |a|one can also choose b=0 and a phase attaining an available negative output. Therefore the strict bound is necessary for the guarantee for all b,c.

How did this part go?

Compare your sketch

Expand diagram

Use the scrollbars or arrow keys to inspect details.

All source turning coordinates, y-intercept and asymptotes are retained. An explicitly labelled cosine example lies between −0.5 and 0.5 and avoids the rational graph; the working proves the exact amplitude condition for every phase and frequency.
All source turning coordinates, y-intercept and asymptotes are retained. An explicitly labelled cosine example lies between −0.5 and 0.5 and avoids the rational graph; the working proves the exact amplitude condition for every phase and frequency.
All source turning coordinates, y-intercept and asymptotes are retained. An explicitly labelled cosine example lies between −0.5 and 0.5 and avoids the rational graph; the working proves the exact amplitude condition for every phase and frequency.

Common mistakes

Keep the exact endpoints when stating a strict parameter range; rounding can admit forbidden values.

Solution notes

The source decimal endpoints are rounded versions of the exact strict bounds.

The cosine plotted is only an illustration; the amplitude argument covers every b,c.

Read the hint