Worked solution
Minimise the cone circumscribed about a sphere
A cone of radius and height has volume . A sphere of fixed radius and centre is inscribed in a right cone, touching its base and curved surface, as shown.
(i) Show that . marks
(ii) Use differentiation to find the minimum volume of the cone in terms of , proving it is a minimum. marks
Expand diagramFit diagram to page
Use the scrollbars or arrow keys to inspect details.
[2021/ACJC/I/5]
CJC · Discussion · Question 12
Answer
for ; minimum volume , attained at .
(i) Use the source similar right triangles
Let be the cone apex, its base centre, and the point where the sphere touches a sloping generator in an axial section. Then and , with , so . The similar right triangles and (where is a base-rim point) give . Squaring,
The physical domain is , . Merely requiring would allow impossible cones.
(ii) Form the volume and find its stationary height
Substitute the relation into the cone volume:
The algebraic roots are ; reject as outside the physical domain. Thus the only admissible stationary height is .
Method 1: prove a minimum by the first derivative
For , the factor is positive, so has the sign of . The source sign chart is negative–zero–positive across : the volume falls on and rises on . This proves a minimum throughout the feasible domain.
Method 2: prove a minimum by the second derivative
The quotient rule gives
At , this is . Substituting into the volume gives . Both printed minimum tests are retained.
Common mistakes
The sphere must fit: the cone height exceeds 2a, and the zero-height algebraic root is inadmissible.