Porisma

Worked solution

Connect a derivative discriminant to the missing range

· Techniques of Differentiation

C:y=(x2+a)/(x−a)C:y=(x^2+a)/(x-a), x≠a, where a is a non-zero constant.

(i) Given the oblique asymptote y=x+2, find a. mark

(ii) Find the set of values of a if C has two turning points. marks

(iii) Using a from (i) and an algebraic method, show C cannot exist for y₁<y<y₂, determining y₁,y₂ exactly. marks

(iv) Hence sketch C, clearly showing the asymptotes and stationary-point coordinates. marks

[2010/NYJC/Promo/10]

CJC · Review problems · Question 7

Answer

a=2; two turns for a<−1 or a>0; missing interval 4−26<y<4+264-2\sqrt6<y<4+2\sqrt6.

(i) Divide and compare the oblique asymptote

y=x+a+(a2+a)/(x−a)y=x+a+(a^2+a)/(x-a). Its oblique asymptote is y=x+a; comparison with y=x+2 gives a=2.

How did this part go?

(ii) Require two distinct derivative zeros

y′=[2x(x−a)−(x2+a)]/(x−a)2=(x2−2ax−a)/(x−a)2y'=[2x(x-a)-(x^2+a)]/(x-a)^2=(x^2-2ax-a)/(x-a)^2. Setting this equal to zero gives x2−2ax−a=0x^2-2ax-a=0. Two turns require (−2a)2−4(1)(−a)>0(-2a)^2-4(1)(-a)>0, hence 4a2+4a>04a^2+4a>0, or a(a+1)>0a(a+1)>0. Therefore {a∈R:a<−1 or a>0}\{a\in\mathbb R:a<-1\text{ or }a>0\}. In these intervals a²+a>0, so neither derivative zero is the excluded input x=a; the simple zeros change derivative sign.

How did this part go?

(iii) Form a quadratic in x for a horizontal level

For a=2, y=(x2+2)/(x−2)y=(x^2+2)/(x-2), x≠2. Then y(x−2)=x2+2y(x-2)=x^2+2, giving x2−yx+2y+2=0x^2-yx+2y+2=0. To have no real x, require (−y)2−4(1)(2y+2)<0(-y)^2-4(1)(2y+2)<0, or y2−8y−8<0y^2-8y-8<0.

How did this part go?

(iii) Solve the two boundary levels exactly

The boundary roots are [8±(−8)2−4(1)(−8)]/[2(1)]=(8±96)/2=(8±46)/2=4±26[8\pm\sqrt{(-8)^2-4(1)(-8)}]/[2(1)]=(8\pm\sqrt{96})/2=(8\pm4\sqrt6)/2=4\pm2\sqrt6. Thus 4−26<y<4+264-2\sqrt6<y<4+2\sqrt6 is missing, with y1=4−26y_1=4-2\sqrt6 and y2=4+26y_2=4+2\sqrt6.

How did this part go?

(iv) Put the exact boundary points on the sketch

y=x+2+6/(x−2)y=x+2+6/(x-2), x≠2. The asymptotes are x=2 and y=x+2. The stationary points are (2−6,4−26)(2-\sqrt6,4-2\sqrt6), a maximum, and (2+6,4+26)(2+\sqrt6,4+2\sqrt6), a minimum. The y-intercept is (0,−1); x²+2>0 rules out x-intercepts.

How did this part go?

Compare your sketch

Expand diagram

Use the scrollbars or arrow keys to inspect details.

The two source branches, both exact stationary coordinates and asymptotes are shown. The left branch has a maximum at (2−√6,4−2√6); the right has a minimum at (2+√6,4+2√6).
The two source branches, both exact stationary coordinates and asymptotes are shown. The left branch has a maximum at (2−√6,4−2√6); the right has a minimum at (2+√6,4+2√6).
The two source branches, both exact stationary coordinates and asymptotes are shown. The left branch has a maximum at (2−√6,4−2√6); the right has a minimum at (2+√6,4+2√6).

Common mistakes

The boundary levels themselves occur at the stationary points; exclude only the open interval.

Solution notes

The exact boundary levels are included in the range, not in the missing interval.

Read the hint