Worked solution
Separate plane angles, intersections and orthogonal directions
Planes are , .
(i) Find their acute angle. marks
(ii) Obtain a vector equation of their intersection line . marks
Another line is , y=m, where m is real.
(iii) If Π1 and l2 intersect at (6,m,5), find m. marks
(iv) Show l1 and l2 are perpendicular for all m. marks
[2010/DHS/II/4(modified)]
CJC · Review problems · Question 4
Answer
Angle 0.162rad or 9.3°; ; (iii)m=−7/4; orthogonal directions for all m, but intersection only at m=−2/5.
(i) Compare the plane normals
The normals have dot product 15 and magnitudes√21,√11. Thus rad(3s.f.), or 9.3°(1d.p.). This acute normal angle is the acute angle between planes.
(ii) Solve both plane equations
and give , . Taking z as a free parameter yields , λ real.
(iii) Substitute the supplied intersection point
gives m=−7/4. The point also satisfies l2 since .
(iv) Prove the orthogonal-direction statement
Writing the common ratio of l2 as μ gives . The direction dot product is , independent of m. Thus their directions are orthogonal for all m, as intended by the printed proof.
(iv) Qualify a spatial intersection interpretation
The two lines intersect only when μ=1/15, λ=34/5 and m=−2/5, found by matching x,z then y. For other m they are skew, despite the orthogonal directions. Therefore “perpendicular for all m” must be read as the angle between directions, not as intersecting at a right angle for every m.
Common mistakes
The source wording in(iv) does not ensure the lines meet.
Solution notes
All four asks and printed working retained. The source all-m perpendicular claim is qualified: direction orthogonality is valid, but intersection occurs only for m=−2/5. No source figure.