Worked solution
When can a conjugate root be assumed?
One of the roots of the equation is , where is a constant.
(i) A student says that “One of the other roots must be .” Explain why this statement is not entirely correct.
(ii) Determine the value of .
(iii) Find the exact values of all the other roots of the equation.
[2009/CJC/I/8(a)]
CJC · Discussion · Question 7
Answer
(i) Reality of p has not yet been established. (ii) . (iii) , .
(i)
The source explanation is that may not be real: the question has not yet stated or established that every coefficient is real. Therefore the conjugate-root theorem cannot yet be invoked on that premise. This concerns the justification at this stage; part (ii) will establish that this particular p is real.
(ii)
Substitute . Its square is , its cube is and its fourth power is . Thus , giving . Hence .
(iii)
Now all coefficients are real, so is a root. The conjugate factors multiply to . Write the remaining factor as . The constant coefficient gives ; the cubic coefficient gives , so . Hence . Solving gives . The other roots are , and .
Common mistakes
The printed criticism is about an unstated premise; after substitution, the student’s proposed root is indeed valid.
Solution notes
The source says “p may not be real” in (i). Because the given root actually forces p=5, the student’s conclusion is true for this polynomial; the missing step is the proof that p is real. This logical qualification is retained rather than claiming the root is false.