Porisma

Original question & working

Split at the absolute-value boundary · source reference

[modified 2008/ACJC/Prelim/I/5] · Question pp. 1 · Working pp. 6

Open the interactive lesson

The working and teaching notes are included in the interactive lesson.

View source review notes
Full original question, working & notes

Complete question

Solve x∣x−2∣≥1x|x-2|\ge1 exactly. [5] Hence solve (x+1)∣x−1∣≥1(x+1)|x-1|\ge1. [3]

[modified 2008/ACJC/Prelim/I/5]

Printed working

Method 1 — graphical

For x∣x−2∣≥1x|x-2|\ge1, the graph intersects y=1y=1 at points A and B.

At A, consider x(x−2)=1x(x-2)=1:

x2−2x−1=0⟹x=2±4+42=1±2.x^2-2x-1=0\quad\Longrightarrow\quad x=\frac{2\pm\sqrt{4+4}}2=1\pm\sqrt2.

Since x>2x>2, x=1+2x=1+\sqrt2.

At B, consider x[−(x−2)]=1x[-(x-2)]=1, giving x2−2x+1=0x^2-2x+1=0. The source then prints (x−1)2=1⇒x=1(x-1)^2=1\Rightarrow x=1; the “=1” is a printed intermediate-line typo: this should be (x−1)2=0(x-1)^2=0.

The two curves intersect at x=1+2x=1+\sqrt2 and x=1x=1. From the graph, the solution is x≥1+2x\ge1+\sqrt2 or x=1x=1.

Method 2 — algebraic

Case 1: For x−2≥0⇒x≥2x-2\ge0\Rightarrow x\ge2:

x(x−2)≥1x2−2x−1≥0(x−1)2−2≥0(x−1−2)(x−1+2)≥0x≤1−2orx≥1+2.\begin{aligned} x(x-2)&\ge1\\ x^2-2x-1&\ge0\\ (x-1)^2-2&\ge0\\ (x-1-\sqrt2)(x-1+\sqrt2)&\ge0\\ x&\le1-\sqrt2\quad\text{or}\quad x\ge1+\sqrt2. \end{aligned}

Intersecting this union with x≥2x\ge2 gives x≥1+2x\ge1+\sqrt2.

Case 2: For x−2<0⇒x<2x-2<0\Rightarrow x<2:

x(2−x)≥1⇒x2−2x+1≤0⇒(x−1)2≤0⇒x=1.x(2-x)\ge1\Rightarrow x^2-2x+1\le0\Rightarrow(x-1)^2\le0\Rightarrow x=1.

Intersecting x<2x<2 and x=1x=1 gives x=1x=1.

Taking the union, the solution to x∣x−2∣≥1x|x-2|\ge1 is x≥1+2x\ge1+\sqrt2 or x=1x=1.

Replace xx with x+1x+1. The solution for (x+1)∣x−1∣≥1(x+1)|x-1|\ge1 is

x+1≥1+2orx+1=1⟹x≥2orx=0.x+1\ge1+\sqrt2\quad\text{or}\quad x+1=1\quad\Longrightarrow\quad x\ge\sqrt2\quad\text{or}\quad x=0.

Teacher margin notes

At A, x>2x>2, so ∣x−2∣=x−2|x-2|=x-2.

At B, x<2x<2, so ∣x−2∣=−(x−2)|x-2|=-(x-2).

The blue curve is above or intersects the red curve.

Source diagrams

Source-specific plot of y=x|x−2| and y=1; B at x=1 is a tangency and A at x=1+√2 is a crossing, with corner at x=2.

Provenance

Question page references: 1. Solution page references: 6. The original compilation header and printed page numbers are preserved in the edition notes. Original PDFs and page images remain only in the private QA archive.