Porisma

Original question & working

Turn a curve sketch into its gradient graph · source reference

modified 2010/RVHS/Prelim/II/1 · Question pp. 1 · Working pp. 3

Open the interactive lesson

The working and teaching notes are included in the interactive lesson.

Roots of f need not be roots of its derivative.

View source review notes
Full original question, working & notes

Printed question

The diagram shows the graph of y=f(x)y=f(x). The curve passes through the origin OO, the points A(−4a,0)A(-4a,0) and C(−2a,0)C(-2a,0). The points B(−3a,2)B(-3a,2) and D(−a,−2)D(-a,-2) are stationary points and the lines y=0y=0 and x=ax=a are asymptotes of the curve.

Sketch the graph of y=f′(x)y=f'(x), indicating clearly the points corresponding to AA, BB, CC and DD, and the asymptotes, where applicable. [2]

[modified 2010/RVHS/Prelim/II/1]

Printed working

The printed solution is the native derivative sketch below: B′(−3a,0)B'(-3a,0) and D′(−a,0)D'(-a,0) are its intercepts, with asymptotes x=ax=a and y=0y=0. At the abscissae of AA and CC, the derivative is respectively positive and negative; numeric ordinates are not supplied.

Teacher notes

  1. Asymptotes: asymptotes x=ax=a, y=0y=0 of curve y=f(x)y=f(x) remain as asymptotes of curve y=f′(x)y=f'(x) in the supplied sketch.

  2. Stationary points B,DB,D of curve y=f(x)y=f(x) become xx-intercepts B′,D′B',D' of curve y=f′(x)y=f'(x) since f′(x)=0f'(x)=0 at B,DB,D.

  3. Map out the graph by tracing the gradient of curve y=f(x)y=f(x) as xx increases.

Note: curve y=f(x)y=f(x) decreases (i.e. curve BB to DD) / increases ⇒ gradient <0<0 / >0>0 ⇒ curve y=f′(x)y=f'(x) lies below / above the xx-axis.

Qualification: the asymptote rule describes this particular source sketch, not every differentiable function with a horizontal asymptote.

Answer key

Same derivative sketch as the detailed solution.

Native diagrams

Original f sketch: A, B, C, D, O, x=a and y=0. Derivative sketch with B′, D′, A′ and C′ signs, and asymptotes.